All Forums >> General >> TV, Cinema & Theater

Book v film (by chunkymonkey67)

 chunkymonkey67 
8-Aug-13 9:37 am
Do you prefer to read a book or watch a film based on the book,sometimes the book is better than the film and vice versa,which do you favour and have you been let down by a film based on a book

 

 

 
 
 Martian 
8-Aug-13 9:44 am
None of the Batman movies were as good as the orginal comic books

 

 

 
 
 Zilya777 
8-Aug-13 9:46 am
@chunkymonkey67: A book, most definitely. Years ago, I read Jaws & ET. But paying to see there in a theather.... Big disapointment. Since then, usually the book first. The "Millinium" triolgy. Was great. And the Swenden movies from it. But the American version of " the girl with a dragon tatoo" Was American.... & so very different what the writer wrote... That I hated it.

 

 

 
 
 chunkymonkey67 
8-Aug-13 9:52 am
@Zilya777: read the jaws book and have to agree,more detail in the book than the film,still didn't have a bath for a week or two after the film though lol

 

 

 
 
 TheCelt (4)   (44 / M-F / Ireland)
8-Aug-13 9:56 am
I rarely read books and when i do i hardly ever finish them . So i much prefer watching a film . Cuz it takes much less effort :p . I did listen to the audio book for world war z though before watching the film . But they were so different that you cant really compare the two and say which one is better

 

 

 
 
 anncleofaye 
8-Aug-13 10:12 am
Hmm i prefer to read books, ive tried to read twilight series and harry potter before and books are much better than movie. juz saying.

 

 

 
 
 Zilya777 
8-Aug-13 11:15 am
@Zilya777: read the jaws book and have to agree,more detail in the book than the film,still didn't have a bath for a week or two after the film though lol
There is more "detail" in a book. And books are more focused on "Charater Studies/Personaities" Where as American "Hollywood " movies are (admittedly) geared to a 25 yr old. Ugh.... So less story, more special effects, more skin, sex, violence, music. So im a big fan of books, & Non-American movies. (& TV shows ) I want the truth or a story, not FLASH. And deffinitely adults acting like real life adults.

 

 

 
 
 LonelyCritter (8)   (62 / M-F / Illinois)
8-Aug-13 11:19 am
Book, hands down! Take kids to Barns and Noble, have a coffee, they get to get a few books, and I get to relax!

 

 

 
 
 duelmasterelite 
8-Aug-13 11:20 am
What is a book

 

 

 
 
 RussellB 
8-Aug-13 1:20 pm
Heck I like both. I'm a huge movie buff but I also love curling up with a good book... Except porn. I'd rather watch that.

 

 

 
 
Quick reply:

[Smilies]

RULES:
  • Be respectful at all times.
  • Be mature and act like an adult.
  • Respect different points of view.
  • Discuss ideas, not specific users.
  • Don't get personal.
  • No profanity.
  • No drama.
  • No thread hijacking.
  • No trolling.
  • No spamming.
  • No soliciting.
  • No duplicate posting.
  • No posting in the wrong section.
  • No posting of contact information.
  • Be welcoming to new users.
Repeated violations of the above will result in increasing temporary bans from the forum and an eventual permanent ban from the site. Basically, just be friendly and neighborly and all will be well.
Similar threads:
Top
Home
Give us feedback!

Login:

* Username:

* Password:

 Remember me


Forgot?